What each part of the prompt does
- Resources as an input
- The same idea can be a go for someone with industry contacts and a stop for someone without. Asking what you bring makes the verdict about you and this idea, not about the idea in general.
- Build or buy
- Step 2 asks which hard parts could be bought or outsourced. Many early ideas look impossible until you notice that the difficult piece already exists as a service you can pay for.
- Formulas, not figures
- Showing the money logic as price times customers minus costs, rather than invented totals, tells you exactly which three or four numbers you need to look up or test.
- Tests that change the verdict
- Each test comes with the result that would flip the answer. That keeps you from running experiments whose outcome would not change anything you do next.
Variations to try
Same idea, one thing changed.
Comparing three ideas You are a business analyst who runs feasibility checks for early ideas. I am choosing between three ideas: [BUSINESS IDEA] Industry: [INDUSTRY] Where we would sell first: [REGION] What I can bring: [MY RESOURCES] What I have already checked: [EVIDENCE] Score each idea from 1 to 5 on problem strength, difficulty to build, ease of reaching customers, money logic and fit with my resources, with one line of reasoning per score. Pick the one to test first and give two cheap tests for it. Do not invent statistics.
Service business version You are a business analyst who checks whether a local service business can work. The idea: [BUSINESS IDEA] Industry: [INDUSTRY] Where we would operate: [REGION] What I can bring: [MY RESOURCES] What I have already checked: [EVIDENCE] Cover demand in the area, how customers book similar services today, licences or insurance to check, how many jobs a week are needed to cover costs (as a formula), and the first ten customers I could realistically reach. End with go, pivot or stop and two tests for the next 30 days. Do not invent statistics.
If the result isn't right
- Write "nothing yet" in [EVIDENCE] if that is the truth. The tests at the end are only useful if they start from what you actually know.
- If the verdict is pivot, ask "give me two pivots that keep my resources but change the customer" before you drop the idea.
- Items marked "verify" are the first things to search: local directories, app stores and price lists of similar businesses.